simplify.education

Statistics · BEGINNER LESSON

P value

A P value is a conditional probability: assuming the null hypothesis is true, it is the chance of getting data at least as extreme as the data observed. It is a measure of evidence against the null hypothesis, not the probability that the null hypothesis is true.

What a P value is

A P value is a number used in hypothesis testing, a statistical method for judging whether sample data are unusual under a starting assumption called the null hypothesis, often meaning “no effect” or “no difference.” The P value answers one specific question: if the null hypothesis were true, how likely would we be to see data this extreme or more extreme by chance alone? Smaller P values mean the observed data are less compatible with the null hypothesis, so they provide stronger evidence against it. [0,1,2]

[1] The P Value: What It Is and What It Is Not - PMC [2] P Value and the Theory of Hypothesis Testing - PMC - NIH [3] The P Value: What Is It and What Does It Tell You? - PMC - NIH

How it is used

Researchers compare the P value with a chosen significance level, often 0.05. If the P value is below that cutoff, they may reject the null hypothesis in favor of an alternative hypothesis, which says there is some effect or difference. This is a decision rule, not a direct statement that the hypothesis is true or false. The Neyman-Pearson framework also uses Type I error, meaning false rejection of a true null hypothesis, and Type II error, meaning failing to reject a false null hypothesis. [0,1]

[1] The P Value: What It Is and What It Is Not - PMC [2] P Value and the Theory of Hypothesis Testing - PMC - NIH

What it does not mean

A P value is not the probability that the null hypothesis is true, not the probability that the alternative hypothesis is true, and not the probability that a similar study will give the same result. A small P value also does not tell you how big or important an effect is. Statistical significance means the observed result is unlikely under the null hypothesis; clinical significance asks whether the size of the effect matters in real practice. [0,1,2]

[1] The P Value: What It Is and What It Is Not - PMC [2] P Value and the Theory of Hypothesis Testing - PMC - NIH [3] The P Value: What Is It and What Does It Tell You? - PMC - NIH

Mechanism and limits

P values are shaped by both the observed effect and the sample size. A small study can miss a real effect and produce a non-significant P value, while a very large study can make a tiny effect look statistically significant. Because of this, P values should be read with effect sizes, confidence intervals (CIs), and study context. They also do not establish causation by themselves, and replication is important before accepting a claim. [0,1,2]

[1] The P Value: What It Is and What It Is Not - PMC [2] P Value and the Theory of Hypothesis Testing - PMC - NIH [3] The P Value: What Is It and What Does It Tell You? - PMC - NIH

SEE THE IDEA

How to read a P value

Assumption -> observed data -> probability under that assumption -> statistical decision plus interpretation

A P value is one piece of evidence in a broader analysis; it is not the whole conclusion.

TRY IT YOURSELF

Test your understanding

Choose an answer, then check the explanation.

0 of 3 questions answered
01 A study reports P = 0.03. What does this mean?
02 A new trial has P = 0.20, but the measured difference is large. What is the best interpretation?
03 Two studies test the same treatment. Study A has a very large sample and P = 0.04; Study B has a small sample and P = 0.08. Which scenario is most consistent with the sources?

PUT IT TOGETHER

Match each concept to its meaning

Drag a label onto its description, or select a label and then select a description. This also works with a keyboard.

Sources and further reading

This general lesson was generated from public source material. It explains a concept; it does not interpret a private paper or provide medical advice.

  1. The P Value: What It Is and What It Is Not - PMC
  2. P Value and the Theory of Hypothesis Testing - PMC - NIH
  3. The P Value: What Is It and What Does It Tell You? - PMC - NIH
Apply this to a paper →